Yes, How Many Carbs Per Day Should A Diabetic Type 2 Limit Them Selves To | DiabetesTeam

Connect with others who understand.

sign up Log in
Resources
About DiabetesTeam
Powered By
Real members of DiabetesTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.
Yes, How Many Carbs Per Day Should A Diabetic Type 2 Limit Them Selves To
A DiabetesTeam Member asked a question 💭
posted October 18, 2021
•
View reactions
A DiabetesTeam Member

The answer to that question is "it depends on what your goals are".

For those that want to manage "without medication" or at the minimal level possible, a couple large studies have determined that you can "NOT Exceed" 130 Net Carbs a day.

Beyond that, depending on how much you are willing to medicate the answer is almost limitless.

There are drugs such as Sulfonylurea's or Bolus Insulin that will metabolize as many as you want to eat.

Of course if the dosage is a little off you can really mess yourself up. My Aunt destroyed her Kidneys trying this method - just eat "whatever you want" and dial up the insulin - it wasn't pretty.

If you follow the Food guide for Diabetes they recommend about 200 carbs a day "with whatever medication is required".

What complicates the matter is Type 2 is a Metabolic Disorder. So while I can generally tolerate about 120 carbs a day and stay in my range, there is a couple members here that can not exceed about 40 carbs a day without having blood sugar problems and others that handle 150 a day and do well.

If you do any (self testing) then you can figure out what "YOUR" number actually is. You figure out the carbs for a given meal, check your blood sugar after, if it's good, eventually you will figure out "how many per meal" you can metabolize and stay in range.

That is the only real way to answer your question. But if you are starting from scratch and willing to make adjustments if necessary, I would try 150 a day - 3 meals @ 40 carbs max and a couple of 15 carb snacks.

posted October 18, 2021
A DiabetesTeam Member

@A DiabetesTeam Member yes those are "food guide for diabetic" guidelines with the caveat that the (patient) WILL use medication to deal with the excess blood sugar for eating those guidelines

And for "total health" those recommendations are valid

You have to remember that professionals "treat" - so here, eat this all round healthy "balanced" (menu) and when your blood sugar jacks up we will give you some pills to fix that

There is no "guideline" for "I would rather not take meds or keep them to a minimum"

Although all the major diabetes organizations now at least acknowledge that there is "possibly some value" to low carb diets for diabetics, in particular Diabetes Canada advises that there has been positive results and the diet may be valid but (paraphrased) there is insufficient long term data to prove that it works beyond the first couple of years

My response to that is "seriously"???

They have been preaching the Food Guide with 40 to 60% of total calories from Carbs for about 4 decades and 70% of Type 2's are "totally uncontrolled" - all the "long term historical data" on their current dietary recommendations are SHOUTING - IT DOESN'T WORK and when they see two or three years of positive results that are from a diet contrary to their "non-working method" they say "hang on, we don't how long it will work for"....

The DiRECT Trial conducted for a decade in the UK is now the guideline for Diabetes UK - it determined that carbs should be restricted to 26% of total calories - that equates to about 130 carbs/day in a 2000 calorie diet

That would be cut up into 3 meals X 32.5 carbs and 2 snacks at about 16 carbs each "maximum"

I eat 4 X 25-35 carb meals a day, no snacks, and maintain a Sub 6.0 A1C without any anti-diabetic meds

So at least for "me" the UK guidance works (with a bunch of caveats)

PS - if you want to read some "leading edge mainstream management advice on Diabetes poke around the Diabetes UK website - they are "serious" unlike our orgs - particularly have a look that their "ongoing" IMPACT study/program - an intensive weight loss/sugar management protocol with close doctor intervention for patients who have said "I want to do this on my own" - because the Brits have figured out it's cheaper to prevent complications then deal with them when they develop

posted January 30, 2023 (edited)
A DiabetesTeam Member

Thank you Graham, you have been most helpful

posted October 19, 2021
A DiabetesTeam Member

Check and Familiarize with the Lily Guide on meal planning. Know how much to eat. Especially if u are eating out at a fast food restaurant. Keep the guide downloaded on your phone. And check when not sure.

posted January 31, 2023
A DiabetesTeam Member

Information very key Graham.
I think this speaks fir itself as you are Type 2 great control without Ned's. Fantastic. So you have 4 meals per day with about 2 servings if carbs per meal. OK. That is very encouraging. Definitely gonna read up on the British recommendations for diabetes. Are these recommendations for type 2 who do not take insulin? Are they the same for diabetics..
I would be very interested in trying yiur carb control which represents insulin dependent ones like me. Sounds very doable.
How do u coach / teach patients about servings and how much if a particular amount if food equals 1 serving carbs. Reading food labels is a good tool. But ...
This is tge reason why I find tge meal planning guide from Eli Lily so useful.
Examples from Lily document
1 slice of bread = 1 serving of carbs = 15 - 18 grams of carbs
1/2 cup of cereal or half cup of rice = apprix 15 grams of carbs.
U have had excellent success using this method and its worth a try.

posted January 31, 2023

Related content

View All
Is There A Specific Diet That Tells You What To Eat?
A DiabetesTeam Member asked a question 💭
How Do Some Of You Stay So Low On Carbs? I Mean Those Of You Under 50 Or 30 Carbs.
A DiabetesTeam Member asked a question 💭
Why Isn't The The Info About The Benefits Of Low Carb Diet For Diabetics, Reaching More People?
A DiabetesTeam Member asked a question 💭
Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
Lock Icon Your privacy is our priority. By continuing, you accept our Terms of use, and our Health Data and Privacy policies.
Already a Member? Log in